Not at the same time. Split Pay supports one active split at a time today; splitting more than one bill is something we hope to offer in the future.
How to think about which one to choose:
Pick the one where splitting helps you most. Usually that's the larger payment, or the one whose due date lines up worst with your paycheck.
Pick the one with less flexibility on its own. Some lenders and landlords are more flexible than others when you need a few extra days — pick the bill where splitting saves you the most friction.
Common patterns:
Rent is usually the bigger bill → split rent, make your car payment in full from cash
Rent date is tight with your paycheck → split rent for breathing room, make your car payment on its own schedule
Your auto servicer has stricter late-fee policies than your landlord → consider splitting the car payment instead
You can switch between them. If you split rent this month and want to split the car payment next month, that's possible: pay off your second payment (it settles in 3–5 business days), tap Cancel Plan in Plan Details, remove your Split Pay account and routing numbers from the old portal or servicer, then apply for the new bill right away. See the FAQ on Can I switch which bill I use Split Pay for?.